SANTA CRUZ — With the final certification of votes by the Santa Cruz County Clerk Tuesday afternoon, the ballot initiative in the city of Santa Cruz known as Measure Z, or the Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Tax, has officially passed.
According to the Santa Cruz County Elections Department, 15,780 votes were counted in favor of the ballot initiative, or about 52%, and 14,364 votes, or approximately 48%, were counted against the passage of Measure Z.
The Yes on Measure Z for a Safe and Healthy Santa Cruz campaign was led by Santa Cruz City Councilmembers Martine Watkins, Sonja Brunner and Shebreh Kalantari-Johnson, who expressed their gratitude toward community members, volunteers and organizations that supported the effort.
“We are incredibly proud of the hard-fought campaign for Measure Z and deeply grateful to the voters of Santa Cruz for their support,” said Watkins. “This victory represents a collective stand for public health, community well-being and the power of local democracy.”
Kalantari-Johnson added, “Despite being outspent $1.9 million to our $85,000 by corporate special interests, the people of Santa Cruz stood strong and made their voices heard. This outcome is a testament to the strength of community organizing, the dedication of community advocates and the commitment of our residents to create a healthier future for all.”
Steve Maviglio, spokesperson for the opposition group called Campaign for an Affordable Santa Cruz, pointed out that the race was a close one, with the measure passing by about 1,400 votes, and that the tax could face legal challenges moving forward.
“State law governs this matter, and the law says local taxes on groceries are illegal in California,” said Maviglio. “The fact that the vote is this close shows that even in the most progressive communities in California, voters are standing up to a regressive tax that hurts working families, local businesses and their employees. This is no surprise given the strong support for the statewide ban on local grocery taxes passed in 2018 by the legislature, and we are grateful for the progressive leaders, labor unions, small business owners, students and residents who came together to keep Santa Cruz affordable and oppose this unfair tax.”
The history of the sugar-sweetened beverage tax in the city goes back to 2018 when a 1.5-cent-per-ounce sugary drink tax ballot initiative, championed by Watkins and others, was approved by the Santa Cruz City Council to go to a vote by city residents that November.
The initiative was brought to an end two days later when then-Gov. Jerry Brown signed the Keep Groceries Affordable Act into law in June 2018 that prevents taxes on grocery items until 2031, and included a penalty provision that would take away all of a city’s sales and use tax revenue if any charter city attempted to implement a grocery-related tax such as a soda tax.
After the act was passed, then-Santa Cruz City Manager Martin Bernal suggested the measure be taken off of the 2018 ballot in fear of the penalty, and it was removed by the City Council.
In 2020, a lawsuit was filed by Jarvis, Fay & Gibson, LLP on behalf of Watkins and Fresno-based nonprofit Cultiva La Salud. ChangeLab Solutions and the American Heart Association also supported the legal action. In fall 2021, the Sacramento County Superior Court ruled that the Keep Groceries Affordable Act’s penalty provision was unconstitutional and unenforceable. The state then appealed the court’s decision.